Warrington-Worldwide.co.uk incorporates the Village Life, Culcheth Life, Frodsham Life & Lymm Life magazines.

Tory candidate accuses Labour MPs of “blatantly misleading public” over NHS charges


WARRINGTON’s two MPs have been accused of “blatantly misleading the public for political gain” following a demonstration outside the town’s hospital at the weekend after reports NHS patients faced charges of £18,000 for hip operations.

Commenting on Labour’s protest outside Warrington Hospital on Saturday, Warrington South Tory Parliamentary Candidate Andy Carter said it demonstrated “an on-going weaponization of our Health Service by Warrington’s Labour MPs who were blatantly misleading the public for political gain.”

He added: “I listened with surprise to the comments made by Faisal Rashid MP and Helen Jones MP in House of Commons on Thursday that ‘Our hospital was demanding £18,000 before they carry out a hip operation, they were simply repeating a story which appeared in a tabloid newspaper earlier in the day. A story which wasn’t true, where the hospital had told the journalists it wasn’t true and where the Labour politicians knew it wasn’t true”.

Andy Carter at Warrington Hospital

“The hospital doesn’t make decisions on who receives treatment, deciding who is treated by our NHS is completely separate to the NHS Trust that provide our care. The pricing list they focused on was launched in September 2018, has never been used, and is to give options for those who don’t meet the criteria for treatment under NHS commissioning rules. Our MPs surely know how the NHS works, if they don’t, they need to spend time researching before standing up and making claims.”

“What makes me even more angry is the blatant hypocrisy of Labour politicians, who stand on Lovely Lane claiming to be the party of the NHS. This is the same party who were responsible for the decisions which led to the first hospital being privatised in the UK.

“As far back as 2006, then Health Secretary Alan Johnson announced that poor performing Managers would be replaced with private companies. In March 2010, when Andy Burnham was Health Secretary, the Labour government shortlisted three private companies to take over Hichingbrooke Hospital in Cambridgeshire with the contract later being awarded to a company called Circle. Mr Rashid seems oblivious to the facts that it was the Conservative government who later returned this hospital to NHS Management”.

“Last year the Prime Minister announced a £20.5 billion funding settlement and a ten-year plan for the NHS, more doctors, more nurses and extra funding to ensure that we can deliver world-class health care. I want to see our share of that additional funding for our NHS care services here in Warrington, we need a bigger and better Hospital which is fit for the next 50 years. Rather than spending time repeating false information he should be at the department for Health asking what money can be allocated to our town”.

“Protesting outside a hospital also shows a complete lack of understanding for the people using the hospital, the relatives of the sick and elderly and the staff who work there. Having recently spent time there with a very sick relative, the last thing you want when leaving the building is to be faced with a very noisy group of people waving placards”.

Last week the Trust’s Chief Exceutive Mel Pickup has hit back at reports suggesting NHS patients were facing charges of up to £18,000 for hip operations and other procedures, saying “NHS patients do not pay for NHS treatments.”

In a memo to staff and published on the hospital website she said: “You may be aware of the current media coverage regarding the above scheme. I would like to reassure you about this.

“For the avoidance of doubt, I would wish to be very clear that Warrington and Halton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust does not charge NHS patients for NHS treatments and we have no intention of doing otherwise.

“It is not the role of hospitals to determine which treatments are funded by the NHS and which are not; this is the role of NHS commissioners.

“Present for many years, there is a growing list of procedures that our commissioners will no longer pay for if criteria are not met. The Trust does not make decisions with regards to
eligibility for such procedures.

Prior to the hospital demonstration on Saturday Mr Rashid called on the government to issue an urgent statement and allow MPs to debate the introduction of pricing lists by Warrington and Halton Hospitals Trust (WHH), following reports that the Trust had started to advertise operations that had previously been performed for free on the NHS.

Responding to Mr Carter’s criticism he said: “I am disappointed but not surprised to discover that rather than criticising the ongoing privatisation of our NHS, the Conservative Party candidate for Warrington South sees fit to criticise those fighting to prevent it.

“Because make no mistake: these measures are the direct outcome of nearly a decade of crippling NHS underfunding by a Tory-led Government.

“The introduction of a ‘price list’ for treatments that were previously free of charge on our NHS is blatant privatisation. If Conservative politicians cannot see this then I seriously question their suitability for elected office.

“I am glad that the Warrington and Halton Hospital Trust have acknowledged this by halting their proposed ‘My Choice’ programme, which would have charged patients over £18,000 for a hip and knee replacement. This shows what we can achieve when we fight to protect an NHS which is always free at the point of use.

“I am sure it is blatantly obvious to my constituents why I was protesting outside Warrington Hospital: I will not simply stand idly by and see the sick and vulnerable in our community have to worry about self-funding basic treatment and care. To suggest I was protesting out of a lack of respect or understanding for NHS patients is disingenuous in the extreme and frankly insulting.

“The Tories are running our NHS into the ground and I will continue to oppose them at every turn.”

Warrington North MP Helen Jones also raised the issue in parliament and called for a debate to held to discuss the ‘creeping privatisation’ of the National Health Service and the ‘denial of essential treatments to people that cannot afford to pay for them.’

Ms Jones has also tabled a number of Questions to the Secretary of State for Health in relation to this matter.

She said at the time: “It is outrageous for our local NHS Trust to restrict access to essential operations and then seek to charge amounts that no one on a normal wage can pay.”

Hospital suspends controversial charging service


About Author

Experienced journalist for more than 35 years. Managing Director of magazine publishing group with six in-house titles and on-line daily newspaper for Warrington. Experienced writer, photographer, PR consultant and media expert having written for local, regional and national newspapers. Specialties: PR, media, social networking, photographer, networking, advertising, sales, media crisis management. Patron Tim Parry Johnathan Ball Foundation for Peace. Trustee Warrington Disability Partnership. Former Chairman of Warrington Town FC.


  1. Well – I’m not sure what to make of this – it’s taken me 3 years to find out that my hips are shot to bits – two months ago I convinced my doctor to send me for an x-ray to see why I’ve got pains everywhere below my hip line and a bruising on my left groin – there was a four month waiting list to see someone. By chance I saw a sign for an osteopath in Culcheth – I was fed up with not being able to put my socks on or cut my toe nails. He asked me about my x-ray doing the assessment said that my hips needed replacing especially the right hand one. He managed to get my right hip realigned ( I apologised for swearing) and he said oh that’s ok roll over and I’ll do the left. For some reason I can’t walk far and lag behind my wife like a puppy dog but I can still run – must be the adrenalin. On my 2nd visit I told him I’d managed to do the Birkenhead parkrun but it has taken 1 hour – he told me that after this session I would run faster and at Widnes I knocked off 20 minutes with a time of 39 mins, however my pb back in the day on my club athletic track at Victoria Park I ran the 5km in 14.45 so a long way to go yet. However he said that was all he could do for now and that an operation was the only way forward. So I will soon find out what the score is and I’m hoping to return like Andy Murray – but small step first – I’d love to be able to put my socks on or ride a bike again.

  2. Perhaps Andy Carter already has Private Healthcare? Or he and his family enjoy exceptionally good health? Because he doesn’t seem to be aware of the difficulties of getting treatment/an operation on the NHS these days. First you need to get a diagnosis from a consultant, – at the doctors surgery I attend you’ve got to be half dead before you can get a referral to a consultant! When you finally get the referral, there’s a waiting list, then when you finally get to see the consultant he orders tests and you wait further to get them done and then wait further for an appointment to see the consultant to get results of the tests. If, after his diagnosis, you are referred for treatment (presuming it’s on the list the NHS will fund) you go on another waiting list. All this can take an age! because the NHS is underfunded, overstretched and badly managed. a big problem is shortage of beds – if they start using these beds for private patients, the waiting lists for everyone else will obviously get longer! The ‘choice’ system is, together with proposed tax cuts for a high earners, just another benefit for the better off – it cuts their private healthcare costs. As time goes by, the increasingly long waiting lists will force desperate people to pay the ‘choice’ fees until it becomes the norm. Privatisation through the back door!

Leave A Comment