By Simon Plumb
LYMM were left to rue a series of missed scoring opportunities after suffering a narrow 30-26 home defeat against Cinderford in an entertaining encounter at Beechwood.
On a beautiful but breezy autumn afternoon, Lymm welcomed the Gloucestershire visitors knowing they would provide a stern test, having beaten league leaders Redruth the previous week.
And so it proved, with Lymm producing plenty of attacking rugby but ultimately being punished by Cinderford’s clinical finishing and resolute defensive display.
Lymm started brightly, moving the ball well and putting the visitors under pressure, but struggled to turn their possession into points.
Back-row forward Fin Williams was held up over the line as the hosts threatened, while Cinderford also failed to capitalise on an opportunity from close range at the other end.
However, a penalty conceded by Lymm under the posts allowed the visitors to take an early 3-0 lead after 10 minutes.
Lymm continued to press and, despite initially opting for a scrum rather than a straightforward penalty attempt, eventually found a breakthrough.
Following further attacking pressure, a quickly taken penalty created the opening for impressive back-rower Rhys Lilley to score to the left of the posts. Tom Shard added the conversion to put Lymm 7-3 ahead after 20 minutes.
The home side looked increasingly dangerous, with some slick handling and well-worked attacking moves, but the final execution was letting them down.
A promising line-out opportunity was lost after the throw was deemed not straight, while other promising attacks broke down through handling errors and inaccurate kicking.
Cinderford’s defensive resilience was proving difficult to break, and they delivered a significant blow just before half-time.
With Lymm pressing inside the visitors’ 22, Cinderford broke away following a controversial incident around a maul, with their left winger racing approximately 75 metres to score under the posts.
The converted try put the visitors back in front at 10-7 as the half-time whistle approached.
HALF-TIME: LYMM 7-10 CINDERFORD
Cinderford struck again early in the second half after winning a line-out following an excellent 50-22 kick.
A powerful rolling maul created the platform before the ball was moved wide and a back-row forward broke through to score under the posts, extending the visitors’ advantage to 17-7.
The two tries either side of half-time left Lymm with plenty of work to do, and matters were made worse when influential openside Josh Hadland was forced off with a shoulder injury.
Despite facing an increasingly strong wind, Lymm continued to attack and were again held up over the tryline.
However, an attacking line-out eventually provided the breakthrough, with hooker James Pitcher scoring out wide on the left. The conversion was missed, leaving Lymm trailing 17-12 after 51 minutes.
Cinderford responded by taking a penalty in front of the posts to extend their lead to 20-12.
But Lymm were far from finished. Centre Jack Reynolds produced an excellent individual break, showing quick footwork to breach the visitors’ defensive line and score to the right of the posts.
Shard converted to bring Lymm back to within a single point at 20-19 with 15 minutes remaining.
Another Cinderford penalty restored a four-point advantage, making it 23-19 with 10 minutes left.
Lymm then produced what looked set to be the decisive moment of the afternoon.
After another spell of attacking rugby, Rhys Lilley crossed for his second try of the afternoon, with Shard adding the conversion to put the hosts ahead for the first time since the opening half.
At 26-23, Lymm had finally turned their pressure into a lead and also secured a try bonus point.
But there was one final twist.
Cinderford won a penalty for not releasing and, from the resulting attacking line-out, initially appeared to have their rolling maul halted by Lymm’s defence.
The visitors switched tactics, moving the ball wide and finding their left winger, who finished superbly in the corner for a crucial try.
The conversion from out wide was also successful, putting Cinderford 30-26 ahead with only minutes remaining.
Lymm threw everything into a final assault, with their pack producing a huge surge which drove Cinderford backwards from their own scrum put-in.
But despite sustained pressure, the home side could not find the score they desperately needed before referee Peter Connor brought proceedings to an end.
FULL-TIME: LYMM 26-30 CINDERFORD
It was a frustrating afternoon for Lymm, who created plenty of opportunities but were unable to make the most of their attacking possession.
Cinderford, meanwhile, demonstrated the value of taking points when available and defended resolutely before producing the decisive score when it mattered most.
There was understandable disappointment among the home support, particularly over some key decisions, but Lymm will know that converting more of their chances could have produced a very different result.
Lymm head coach Andy Davies was disappointed with the outcome but praised the quality of the contest.
He said: “I thought it was a terrific game with both teams having spells of pressure and territory. We probably didn’t capitalise on our spell in the first half enough and left some points out there.
“It’s been a fantastic day at the club with four teams playing at home, with our very old defence coach, Tom Bray, playing for the Reapers (vets) as a curtain-raiser.
“Big congratulations to Toby Phillips and the second team, who bounced back with a win today against old rivals Macclesfield, and played some great rugby.”
LYMM FIRST XV
Ben Lilley (53 league appearances), James Pitcher (123), Matty Hand (145), Nathan Ovien (5), Sam Dickenson (22), Fin Williams (11), Josh Hadland (85), Rhys Lilley (104), Tom Manaton (58), Tom Shard (176), Joe Heaton (30), Jack Reynolds (60), James Hampson (9), Will Hitchen (6), Alex Muckerjee (11).
Finishers: Logan Byrne (9), Joe Higgins (48), Max Ure (21), Jamie Cope (8), Cal Morris (90).
Figures in brackets indicate Lymm First XV league appearances.
Referee: Peter Connor.
