Homeowners have trouble deciding between solid wood and MDF, not only for their cabinet doors but also for most of their renovation projects. The popular belief is that wood is solid and durable, while MDF is less durable and flimsy.
While this is inarguably true, the fact is that both solid wood and MDF have their advantages and disadvantages, and before making a purchase, buyers need to consider every aspect. Below we review each material and tell you why MDF is the most favoured when it comes to cabinet doors.
An Overview of Solid Wood
Typically, wood refers to the cut of natural timber from trees. The wood quality will depend on the tree which is harvested from (hardwood or softwood). Natural wood has been effectively used in building to this day. Solid wood will be a perfect choice if you are looking for anything that will last for decades.
Advantages of Solid Wood
- It is solid and long-lasting and therefore, can last for decades without fuss.
- It is artistic, and it stands out because of its grains and pattern.
- Enables ample customization creating room for creativity.
- Wood is typically considered highly valuable.
Disadvantages of Solid Wood
- Prone to damage when exposed to harsh weather elements.
- Expands and contracts with fluctuations in temperature and humidity. This can cause warping and cracking.
- Vulnerable to infestation of bugs and therefore, regular maintenance is needed to protect it from damage.
An Overview of MDF Board
MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard) is an engineered sheet material created from softwood or hardwood residuals that are combined with wax and bind using resin under high temperature and pressure.
When compared with the other engineered sheet materials, MDF is ranked above plywood, and it is dense and durable. As such, it is used in many applications, just like solid wood.
Benefits of Using MDF Board
- It is resistant to warping and cracking.
- Since it doesn’t have noticeable grains, it offers a smooth finish.
- It can effortlessly be customised to fit the style of the door, e.g. panel, raised or insert doors.
- MDF can be made with waterproof surfaces to be used in areas with high moisture content such as a bathroom.
- MDF is cheaper than wood.
Disadvantages of Using MDF Board
- MDF cannot withstand extreme weather elements.
- Hard to restore after scratch.
- It is less durable and robust compared to wood.
So what is the Verdict?
This is not a winner takes all game. Both wood and MDF are essential. This is because each material has its unique advantages and disadvantages. So, there are situations where you will find one material prevailing over the other. One of such situations is the construction of cabinet doors where MDF prevails since it offers more pros than solid wood.
